While I shopped these stores as repositories of craft items (see Heather Mann's blog Dollar Store Crafts) and then as a place for inexpensive toys for the grandchildren, most of the growth in recent years is due to shoppers earning over $70,000 and who are anxious about that. They'll shop using the store's tiny shopping carts, which give the buyer the impression that even a small pile of goods is lavish. The secret of a good dollar store is in the layout and obsessive managers who can monitor 8,000 to 10,000 items.
On a recent stroll through a Dollar General in Topeka, the video above represents what caught my eye as possibly fashion or beauty related. As we shopped, another shopper stalked up and down the aisles loudly complaining to a person on the other end of his phone about some problem he needed to report to the FBI. DH was with me to provide cover for my picture taking, but he actually purchased two packages of men's cotton briefs that day and light bulbs. On another day, we returned to our local Dollar General for two more packages of underwear. 24 new pairs of underwear for $20. Men's underwear sales go down when the economy is in a slump, so perhaps this is a good sign for the American economy. As we drove home, DH did wonder about the working conditions of those who had made his new "small clothes."
You'll notice if you look closely at the items in my video that the majority are MORE than a dollar. Often the stores seem to be in disarray, a fact that seems to be a deliberate marketing strategy. The lines are often long and the clerks morose, as you would likely be if you worked for minimum wage. A recent article by Alice Hines at the Huffington Post wrote about DG's expanded grocery sections. Many of the new DGs have opened in areas that are devoid of supermarkets, or "food deserts." And some studies have found a correlation between diet-related illnesses and living in the vicinity of such stores. There ARE hidden costs to low cost items. Her article went on to describe communities that have fought back against dollar stores that look to open in their area, much as communities have banded against Walmart stores.
I bought nothing myself on this recent window shopping trip, although the bleach IS a bargain. I found myself wondering about shoppers who would not be caught dead shopping in such stores either for ethical reasons or because of the potential to encounter characters like the man on his cell phone. Are there people who would be as nervous to shop a lower end store as I would be to walk into a Hermes-Paris showroom?
Hi Terri, I couldn't seem to get that DG video working...
ReplyDeleteI so hope I didn't make you feel bad... that was certainly not my intention! Just me overcoming my own personal hangups. And I just might ending up posting those figures after all.
It's just that many US and other bloggers often post about these amazing like-new designer items found in thrift stores... that would NEVER happen here. Seriously. NEVER. People with halfway decent clothes to offload take them to a secondhand consignment store and charge considerably more than op shop prices. Likewise fabric, and everything to do with dressmaking is also a lot more expensive. I've lived in the US, and so I do know this. I have to fight down the fear that I'm going to be derided as "extravagant", whereas I really have not much choice but to spend a lot more on my clothes than most of the bloggers I read.
Sorry for rambling! I'm still mulling it over myself...
Carolyn--I've since repaired the video problem. I suspect many of our designer items go to consignment stores. That's a type of shopping I've never really sampled. What explains the high cost of fabric in your area. You ARE not extravagant...in fact, I envy your ability to sew.
DeleteAll of the consignment stores around here are ridiculously priced. I'm not a fan at all.
DeleteTerri, I think I'm game to go into most places to look around. I've shopped (and bought) in places that specialised in dented cans and out-of-date foods (but the out of date contraceptive foam really, really frightened me!). I've shopped (and bought small things) in Harrods and Galleries de Lafayette. The whole thing about workers' conditions is not something I can figure out what to do about. I try to be pleasant or at least not obnoxious to any employees I encounter, but as to making a judgement about where to shop based on working conditions? I would want a pretty unbiased source to tell me how to judge and compare this. Do you know of one? I agree in principle with your Dad that the standard of living is likely to even out over time, but at the moment it looks to me as though it is the middle classes who are most at risk and if that group disappears then it looks to me like we will be back in the dark ages or something. Very serious stuff here! Are you likely to blog about Fussell's book about class? I will look out for it and compare it with Katie Fox's Watching the English. (The video at the top wasn't working for me either, but this is a thought provoking post even so; maybe the guy really did need to speak to the FBI!)
ReplyDeleteOut of date contraceptive foam! Too funny. As a youngster, I felt much freer to walk into high end shops than I do now. I can't quite put my finger on the reason why; perhaps I now understand how I might be scrutinized by the sales staff. Like you, I don't know how to AVOID all the potential ethical lapses in shopping. Like you, I do try imagine a world without the middle class. Don't know that I will quote from Fussell, although his ideas may filter into my writing. The FBI guy was just so loud and crazed...
DeleteOne of difficulties living where I do is shopping at Walmart, so I go other places to avoid it if possible, including the grocery store across the pasture where crazies freak me out. It's another world. Okay. But yes, I don't enjoy shopping in places you're describing, and for many of the reasons your article states. It's hard to be ethical in shopping these days, but places like DG are easy to avoid.
ReplyDeleteThat said, an Oklahoma friend has inspired me to go Good Will shopping in Tulsa. That will be an adventure.
Hermès boutiques are usually very, very nice and welcoming. You'll enjoy it when you're ready, whenever that might be.
Catherine--I've in Oklahoma and I think I understand. Walmart is the only store of significant size in my little town...so about once a month I go, for office supplies & such. I hope you blog about your Goodwill visit!
DeleteI may need more of your gentle encouragement as I keep upscaling my shopping venues of the course of this year.
I don't really do £shops but I do go to charity shops for hidden treasures......I did once date a 20 year old when I was 35 but I couldn't handle it when he would say "never heard of it" to most of my references......some aspects were good though!!
ReplyDeleteYoung at Heart--thanks for the reply to my question on your blog. I had not thought about the reference difficulty although I encounter that in the classroom. Younger guys, I've found, have less rigid ideas about gender roles.
DeleteI visited an antique place today and was amazed by some of the jewelry, gloves and vintage hats I saw.
Then there are those of us, I suppose I am on the younger side in this crew, who believe gender is entirely a social construct and therefore are not just less rigid about gender roles but openly mock them.
DeleteI agree with your Dad about things balancing out. Some of the disruptions in our political life are directly influenced by inequality and the efforts of various interest groups to maintain that.
ReplyDeleteWe heard a lot about food deserts and I'd be interested to know how well it works out when big fresh-food places arrive. I've read accounts of schools that move to fresh lunches and kids pass those items by.
I'm not saying it's hopeless to push markets to carry fresh items, but I think areas get that way because the demand isn't there, and the demand isn't there because of the habits of the residents.
RoseAG--In the summer time, DH & I often make the drive to the big city market down by the river. In recent years, they've opened that up to people shopping with food stamps and that is a definite step in the right direction, though for many inner city folks it likely means a bus ride.
DeleteFirst of all, this is a fascinating post, I had no idea Dollar General was able to beat Dolce & Gabbana in securing DG as a website address. Amazing! I don't know of a DG in Manhattan, though they definitely have dollar stores, even in midtown, and they can be quite popular. I would be hesitant to buy food items from a dollar store but I'd be okay buying other stuff and in fact my husband and I went to our local dollar store fairly often when we lived in the city, you never know what kooky things you'll find. It's funny, he HATES Hermes, I think it made him a nervous wreck when he bought the Ulysse notebook I wanted for my birthday. Those luxury stores and their prices make him extremely uncomfortable. But Catherine (Aesthetic Alterations) is right, I have had good experiences at both the Madison Avenue and Wall Street Hermes boutiques and I have walked into the Wall Street store with my worst wrecked leather bag and still, the very gracious Linda tied a Twilly scarf around the handle of the bag to show me how pretty it would make my bag look. Ha ha, it's like a character test, she's exactly who I buy my scarves from because of that. Dear Terri, if we ever meet and are in NYC I am taking you to an Hermes boutique!
ReplyDeleteAlso, the moonstone ring from Julie Collection is so pretty and delicate. Maybe you should go for it, only $31.20 and you may be able to get free shipping too! XO, Jill
Jill--Yes DG is savvy in their marketing! Somewhere I had read that there many DGs in Brooklyn. My husband is often my moral support when I'm shopping, but I honestly don't know what will happen when I start dragging him into upscale stores. I've converted him to thrifting! Your comment gives me hope that I won't feel too terribly self-conscious when I finally screw up my courage to go into higher end stores. I hope I encounter a clerk (sales associate) as kind as the one you describe. The moonstone ring is a steal!
DeleteI was unable to get the video to work, but I enjoyed your post - you cover so many important topics: financial anxiety, labor conditions in manufacturing plants, and the plight of the minumim wage clerk among them. I find the Dollar Store a great value, but I do feel uncomfortable in there sometimes, like "on whose back am I standing to get this cheap price?" A dilemma.
ReplyDeletePatti--I think I've repaired the problem with the video. We have mostly purchased laundry supplies at such places. Those items don't bother too much--as they are likely bottled and packaged by machine. But anything that is sewn requires a human being somewhere. And we all have to wear underwear.
DeleteThis is an interesting and thought provoking post....
ReplyDeleteJeannie--thank you!
DeleteNo,I didn't have popcorn!!!
ReplyDeleteNot sure why,as I usually love it!
It's just yellow ribbon on the pockets,but what a great idea re sewing tape!!!XXX
I'll be looking for a sewing tape on a future outfit.
DeleteI always feel really weird in dollar stores, and the ones around here everything really IS a dollar. I'll be like, "wait, what? really? this is only a dollar too?" but when I stop to think about it, that's about what most of it is worth. I think it tricks people into buying stuff they don't really need. They are an interesting marketing strategy in general, though.
ReplyDeleteI don't feel weird in dollar stores most of the time, but I am fairly selective in what I buy there. Some of the food items don't actually seem like a bargain to me...they are cheaper at a grocery. I recognize that some folks can't get to a grocery.
DeleteHi Terri - first want to let you know that i tagged you, please go see my blog -
ReplyDeleteDollar stores - there are so many around here, it is a way of life for a lot of folks in my neighborhood, they would not survive without dollar store, they do grocery shopping in Dollar stores around here.
Ariane
Arianne--tagged! Uh-oh
DeleteI suspect that in many areas of the US we will come to see more and more dollar stores.
I try to portion out the newness that is Oklahoma, so I have something interesting to do every week. I got around to Dollar General a few weeks ago. Really fun. Oddly enough, the one thing I bought was bleach.
ReplyDeleteAnd, last week in Paris, my daughter and I went into the Hermes store, (she just wanted to smell the perfume) and the clerk/customer interaction was exactly the same as in the Dollar General. If you needed help, they were there, but you were able to wander all over the store without being bothered. We were quite comfortable.
Beryl--I had to laugh about the bleach! I don't know that there is even a place to buy Hermes in the Kansas City area, although I did stalk a scarf on eBay from a Kansas City seller. I wonder where I got the idea that higher end stores will size a shopper up before they approach them?
DeleteThe ONLY thing I buy at DG is hot sauce! But you can get decent food if you make an effort: ours sells dried beans and other Mexican items (large hispanic population post-Katrina); you can buy milk and eggs (overpriced), peanut butter, coffee, oatmeal--in other words, you could eat just fine. Oh yeah, canned tomatoes and canned corn.
ReplyDeleteMost of the stuff there is imho overpriced. I wish I'd bought stock--I saw the surge in popularity coming.
Frugal--I've bought beans at Big Lots, but I've found that I need to be careful about buying groceries in such places. I have a mental inventory of prices and just as you've said, I can often beat the DG price elsewhere.
ReplyDeleteMy father was a CPA and probably had a far better grasp on overall economic trends than those of us who teach in the Humanities.
This series is fascinating but I can't really add anything except to say that I agree with your Dad about standards of living balancing out.
ReplyDeleteSusan--At the time he was telling me these things, I still couldn't see it. I think he was looking at things in long historical, economic cycles.
DeleteOh my,this really struck a nerve. I abhor Dollar Generals! And I don't know if I can really explain it. They LOOK horrible, just as you mentioned, always in disarray. I love my thrift store shopping and never have any qualms about stepping into even the ugliest looking thrift store. But I just can't bring myself to go into a Dollar General....hmmmmmm....where DOES this come from?!?! Hugs!!! ~Serene
ReplyDeleteI'm not afraid to go into one of these stores, but I typically end up spending money there that I had not planned to.
Delete