Friday, March 16, 2012

The Window Shopping Project: jcpenney




When I walked out of jcpenney, this past Tuesday morning, I had snapped 178 photos within an hour.  The slideshow this week is longer (8 minutes) than the previous ones in my Window Shopping Project.  It progresses from Dresses to Swimwear to Juniors to Intimates & sleepwear to Tights, Purses, Women's Sizes, Shoes, Career dressing, Cosmetics, Jewelry, Sundresses, Boutiques, Jeans.  Having visited three mid-level retail department stores this week, I must say that I was impressed!

The last time I stepped foot in this store was last September when my daughter was shopping a last minute bridesmaid dress.  I was along to corral the grandson.  It was early on a Saturday evening and I found that shopping disorienting.  But since, this store like 1,106 others operating in all 50 U.S. states and Puerto Rico is undergoing a significant change.

The last week in January, Ron Johnson, the same man who launched Apple's retail stores and cut his retail teeth at Target, rolled out "a new logo, a new spokesperson, a new pricing strategy, an investment in Martha Stewart Omnimedia, and another designer partnership with Nanette Lepore."

Johnson has said, "We want our customers to shop on their terms, not ours...By setting our store monthly and maintaining our best prices for an entire month, we feel confident that customers will love shopping when it is convenient for them, rather than when it is expedient for us."  I saw first hand evidence of the new pricing strategy in the juniors department of this store, although the changes will continue through 2015.

No doubt, American readers of my blog have seen clips of Ellen DeGeneres advertisements for jcpenney and perhaps you were part of the controversy surrounding her selection as spokesperson.  She, like Sam Walton before her, once worked for jcpenney.  She is thought to "put the fun back in the retail experience."  And perhaps, the fun in fundamental "Fair and Square" pricing.  "Everyday pricing"  refers to "our regular prices which are always great."  "Month long values" are "even better prices on the things you need now."  And "best prices," which you see some of in my video, indicate "our lowest prices," which "always happen on the 1st and 3rd fridays of every month, while they last."

The new logo alludes to the American flag in a subtle and sophisticated way...and it pervades everything from the merchandising to the shelf tags in the store I visited.

One wonders what James Cash Penney would think of these changes. Penney was one of the founders in 1902 of "The Golden Rule" store in Kemmerer, Wyoming.  Unlike the discount retailers I reviewed in February that sprung up in the American Midwest, Penney's grew in the Rocky Mountain states.    In 1963, J.C. Penney issued its first catalog.  And years ago, I visited a catalog store in rural Montana.  By 1993, J. C. Penney was the largest catalog retailer in the United States.  In 2011, the company announced it would exit the catalog business.

I don't know that I've ever seen the television shopping channel(s) I have read that they developed and I can't say that I have ordered anything from their website,  but I do think there are some exciting changes in store at jcpenneys.

In the hour I spent there, at least three sales assistants inquired whether I needed help, but no one intruded on my shopping experience.   I was pleasantly surprised by the diversity of their assistants and of the clientele.  A woman speaking French made her way with two children through the store.  And only in the shoe department did a male clerk inquire what I might be doing snapping so many photos of the merchandise.  I've never worked in retail so I wonder if employees have to deal with secret shoppers out to scope out quality control.  Do any of my readers have insight about this.

In short, I would shop the revamped jcpenney, especially if I had an occasion for a new dress.  And to answer last week's lingering question--the new approach to merchandising does not appear to extend to the outlet store.

Have any of my readers noticed the changes at jcpenney's?  And what was the last thing you purchased there?

41 comments:

  1. Cute pair of Privo by Clarks sporty shoes was the last thing I bought. ($50) I also got my husband a new juicer. I love the easy to compute pricing - $4, not $3.99. And the prices are really low. without having to figure percent reduction. I also got a pretty bracelet, earrings, and an oblong scarf. It's a huge improvement.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My husband is a big fan of juicers, though we've found several at the thrifts. I agree about the new pricing, because I didn't shop retail, I found it confusing...

      Delete
  2. Thanks for this Terri - I haven't been inside Penney's for quite a while and I think I need to go back for a look. There were some very smart sleeveless dresses in your slideshow, and that canvas bag you admired looks good to me too. And I do need hosiery!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Patti--though I liked the canvas bag, having one would produce the kind of rooting behavior (digging in the depths for something I couldn't see) that I really dislike. I thought the hosiery was an especially good deal.

      Delete
  3. I am so curious to see if this strategy works...YOU are the first place I have actually seen the clothes! I don't think that is good. While Ellen is a funny person, there is absolutely NOTHING about their commericials or their total new strategy that makes me want to go to the store. I like a good deal...to say there are no sales..turns me away. The TV ads do not show any clothes...nothing there to motivate me to go in. Your review is the first time I have thought I should check it out...that is not good. I think they need to change some marketing strategy or this will fall on its face. Of course, just my opinion!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pam--I agree that the commercials mostly address the new strategy in their business rather than the merchandise itself. Perhaps it is notable, that though I shopped, I didn't purchase anything...I'm over-budget already this month! Yikes!

      Delete
  4. Replies
    1. Clara--Welcome to Rags! It helps if you read the post...

      Delete
  5. So fascinating. I am always so impressed by your determination.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LPC--Yes, I'm worried slightly about my project. I think I will hit a point that breezing through some of the upscale stores with my camera...may create a scene.

      Delete
  6. Love the pink! =)

    http://pinkchampagnefashion.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hope--I didn't really care for the color, but I did like the collar.

      Delete
  7. Thank you so much for the tour - once again: ). You are so right, my anxiety grew and grew, as I followed along. SO much stuff, so much of everything.
    Everything looked cleanly organized though. Mango and Levi´s were brands I know/ have seen over here too.
    Definitely a place I simply could not enter in. Just too much of everything.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mette--Your point of view has caused me to realize something about American shopping--the tendency to overwhelm the customer with a sense of "abundance." I've been wondering how intentional it is, designed to keep the customer confused.

      What stores sell Mango in Finland?

      Delete
    2. I have seen Mango´s at Stockmann ( our top department store ). Probably some other stores have it too, but then I would not know, as I visit only certain shops.

      Delete
  8. I was overwhelmed by this store - it looks so huge with row upon row upon row of fluorescent lighting. I can't imagine pushing a cart through everything. Having said that, I was very impressed by how neat the store is, no messy piles, and it's nice that clerks offered to help without being overbearing. Stylewise, I think my favourites were the chevron tights and the colourful sandals - I hope people really buy them! The coral jacket would look great on you. Thanks for the tour and the chance to step into another zone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melanie--I think this was the first store I visited that didn't really feature shopping carts. This Penney's touts itself as a mid-level department store, escalators and the whole bit. The store was far more visually attractive than any store I've visited for my project to date.

      Delete
  9. I haven't been to jcpenney since the new ad campaign started - but I have to say that the new ads are very impressive compared to what they had on before. The catalogue they send in the mail is also very pleasing to the eye.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Waves--I don't receive any clothing catalogues any more! The word must be out that I am a thrifter. I've found some of the ads mildly amusing, but I've had to seek them out on YouTube as we don't watch television at our house.

      Delete
  10. I shop at Penny's fairly regularly. Traffic where I live is terrible and they're nearby.

    I bought a Liz Claiborne knit top a few weeks ago. It's blue/white/green. It looks good with any number of denim items I already own. Target might have had a similar shirt for less but they didn't have it in a print with such good colors so whatever extra I paid was worth it to me.

    I wish them well with their pricing experiement. A lot of people like to do the coupon-retail thing and it may be hard to compete against that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rose--I should have had you guest post this week! That was one interesting aspect about the Liz Claiborne department--the clothing was arranged in such a way that with one item, a shopper has ideas for multiple looks from it. I wish them well too. I know that the lack of coupons would cut down on some of the mailings I receive.

      Delete
  11. I really appreciate your thoughtful review of the new jcp. I've featured some items in my career dressing daily deal posts, and I bought some skirts last year that I was happy with - unfortunately, all now too big as my weight continued to drop. But, yes, I check their circulars and wander through on the rare occasions I go to the local mall.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lynne--So much of my wardrobe has come from thrifts. I've realized that some of the items I've thrifted must have originated at Penney's now that I've studied a few of the tags.

      Delete
  12. Thats a great idea!! To showcase the new inventory for your readers who have not been to the sores recently!! I have not been to a JCP store for long time since there is none nearby where I live. I love their pricing! Hope you are having a wonderful day!
    -Jyoti
    Style-Delights Blog
    Let's Twitter Together
    Friend and Fan on Facebook

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jyoti--I'm doing this project because I am such a thrifter that I don't even know how to shop retail any more. I was very curious about Penney's because of their new approach.

      Delete
  13. Hi, Terri!
    I was able to experience virtually on your You Tube!
    It was very interesting and great!
    I found you on "Style Sud-Est" and followed you now!
    Congratulation winning Arien's broaches!

    akiko in Tokyo
    http://kimonosnack.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Akiko--Welcome to Rags! And isn't Arianne's blog wonderful? She's daring and gives me lots of good styling ideas--wearing my saddle oxfords with a skirt was one. I'll visit soon.

      Delete
  14. I have to admit I had ignored JC penney for several years but after their recent ad campaign had considered whether they might have a new life in them. I'm interested to see what I would think firsthand.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Meri--I haven't shopped any retail in years and years, so I'm really green about retail shopping. I think it would be worth a visit.

      Delete
  15. I wondered if you would be challenged whilst taking photos instore... I think you are brave! I wouldn't have the courage. Of course, jcpenney is not here in Oz :) I also don't think I ever saw a single jcpenney store the entire time I lived in the US either.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Carolyn--You would likely have to visit a huge mall to find a jcpenney store in the states. I know when I'm traveling that malls are low on my priority list--as they are a guarantee of the same merchandise one can find in any American city and not the place to find unique items.

      Delete
  16. I miss our JCPenney store, it closed a couple of years ago. I could usually find a dress there and the yoga outfits they carried fit me the best. It was fun to see what is in the stores today.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Linda--it's always sad to see a store go. I know that I have felt lost without the Borders stores in our area.

      Delete
  17. Penney's was always my favourite mid-range department store, when I was still living in the US. I'm old enough to remember, vividly, the pre-mall days, when our local Penney's was a free-standing store in our then-thriving downtown. (I also got my 1997 wedding gown from the Penney's bridal catalog!)

    It was fun to see what Penney's is like today! Thanks for sharing. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ana--my mother shopped a lot at Penney's when I was growing up. I wonder if they still have a bridal department. I didn't explore the second floor of the store so there may very well still be a bridal salon!

      Delete
  18. This is a really fantastic, thoughtful write-up. I had no idea J.C. Penneys was partnering with Nanette Lepore. I love that line for its prints and dresses so I am even more eager to check out the new JCPs next time I am able to do so.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jesspgh--I think the Nanette Lepore is waiting in the wings. I have worried at points that this Window Shopping project of mine steps on your territory at Consume or Consumed, so it is a relief to learn that I may have something of interest for you here.

      Delete
  19. So interesting reading your post and the comments. I'm so glad I'm not the only one who gets overwhelmed shopping in US stores. Thank God for online shopping or I would still be in rags.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Susan--I'm pretty much of a novice at online shopping too and I suspect that there are all kinds of tricks to that too.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Terri, The last thing I remember buying at Penney's was a green chiffon dress for my friend's wedding (the friend who passed away suddenly last November). I shopped there a lot in my twenties and thirties, for work clothes and shoes, before I discovered thrifting. I took Bill there on one of his early visits to the US and he bought two men's dress shirts which he still says are the best shirts at the best price he's ever found. Given the size of the store and the amount of merchandise, as mentioned by others, I think the only way I'd survive shopping retail would be the same way I approach thrifting - I go in knowing what I want and I look only for that thing. Naturally I don't always find that thing, but if I keep a list I eventually see it somewhere (I picked up a grey/silver scarf in Sydney at a craft shop of all places). Photography in stores could be risking a challenge; in smaller shops I tend to ask first, but they don't always agree.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I was an employee of Penney's and was able to experience firsthand the changes that the new CEO flaunts as "fair and square". The pricing strategies have been revamped (obviously) but what the customer no longer gets is the joy of the coupon chasing game. For this reason, the aisles and fitting rooms no longer line themselves with customers. Also, the biggest issue is the lack of fairness to employees. Management positions are being cut, entire departments erased (most notably the Catalog Dept.), and hours are being cut across the board. Senior full-time associates are being cut from the necessary 40 hours a week to a mere 10. Long-time associates are being encouraged to take an early-retirement package. Management can no longer assure us that jobs will be preserved through these new changes. The customer may see changes to be beneficial, but from behind the scenes, these changes are proving to be malicious.

    ReplyDelete

What's on YOUR mind?